The Complications of Employee Claims: What HR Should Do

claims handed to someone
  • Creating clear-cut policies regarding employee claims is essential for businesses to protect themselves from potential liability.
  • Businesses must have a reliable investigation process when an employee makes a claim.
  • Gathering relevant documentation related to the claim and conducting interviews with all involved parties are essential steps.
  • Establishing an investigation team of representatives from HR and other departments can help employers protect their business from potential liability.

Employee claims can be a difficult and complex topic for businesses to handle. In recent years, the number of employee claims has been steadily increasing as employees become increasingly aware of their rights and are more willing to challenge violations in the workplace. This is especially true in areas such as discrimination or sexual harassment, where there is often little documentation to prove a claim. Unfortunately, it can be challenging for businesses to determine whether an employee’s complaint is valid, leaving them open to liability that could cost them large sums of money in damages.

Employee claims are particularly challenging because they come with a high level of risk. If a company fails to take appropriate action on an employee’s claim, it may be liable for damages caused by the violation. Furthermore, the company may pay hefty legal fees and potential compensation awards if the case goes to court. According to a report from the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), employers paid out $398 million in settlements for claims related to sex-based discrimination alone. This amount does not include any additional costs associated with litigation or legal fees.

As a result, businesses must know what to do with employee claims, especially the human resources division. Here are a few steps to ensure that you’re taking the necessary action to protect your business from potential liability:

Create Clear-Cut Policies

Establishing company policy

Creating clear-cut policies around employee claims is essential for businesses to protect themselves from potential liability. It’s vital for employers to proactively create a workplace environment that is free of discrimination and harassment, as this is one of the most commonly leveled claims in the U.S. Moreover, employers should also ensure that employees know their rights and applicable laws.

Having a written policy on employee claims can help employers establish expectations and protect themselves from liability if a dispute arises. A good policy should list prohibited behaviors in the workplace, such as discrimination or harassment, and clearly outline what actions will be taken if an employee makes a claim. This could include an investigation into the allegations and providing management with guidelines on how to respond if they find there was indeed a violation of policy. Additionally, strong policies can help demonstrate that the business takes allegations seriously and takes steps to address them quickly and effectively.

To ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations, employers must regularly audit their policies surrounding employee claims. This includes reviewing existing documents, updating them when necessary, conducting training sessions with staff on proper procedures, and monitoring ongoing compliance with legal requirements. Doing so helps reduce the risk of costly lawsuits or settlements arising from alleged violations on the part of employees or management. Employers should also provide resources for employees who may need assistance filing complaints or understanding their rights under the law, so they know their protections are being respected.

Establish a Reliable Investigation Process

HR investigating employee disputes

HR should have a reliable investigation process in place for when an employee makes a claim. The goal of any investigation should be to determine the facts of the situation to reach an equitable resolution. Employers should strive to achieve a legally compliant conclusion and respects the rights of all parties involved. If employers fail to take adequate steps during their investigations, they may find themselves open to liability if a court finds them negligent.

Investigating employee claims is a complex and often time-consuming task, but employers need to be strict with the investigation process, including these steps:

Interviewing Involved Parties

The first step is interviewing all involved parties, including the complainant and witnesses. This is important to gain a complete understanding of what happened and to ensure that no information is being withheld or overlooked.

Gathering Relevant Documentation

The next step is to gather any relevant documentation related to the claim, such as emails, reports, or other forms of evidence. This helps employers evaluate the situation more thoroughly and establish a clearer picture of events leading up to the alleged violation. Additionally, it can help provide context for decisions made during the investigation process.

Ensuring Fairness

Finally, employers need to be sure that their investigations are conducted fairly and objectively to avoid potential bias or prejudice against either party. Employers should also take special care to ensure that all parties are treated equally and with respect throughout the process.

Creating an Investigation Team

If you expect employee claims to arrive regularly, creating a team dedicated to investigating them is a good idea. This team should be made up of several members of the HR department as well as representatives from other departments such as legal or finance. If you are building one, you might have to help them get specific certifications. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requires that all people involved in investigations be trained on the rights of individuals with disabilities, for example. ADA training for HR managers might be essential when managing claims by disabled employees.

Provide Follow-Up & Remediation

Once the investigation process has been completed, employers must provide follow-up and remediation where applicable. This could include disciplinary action against any involved parties if they are found to violate policy or law. Additionally, HR should strive to implement measures that prevent similar situations from arising in the future. For example, if an employee complaint involves a manager, it could be beneficial to provide additional training for the manager on handling similar situations in the future.

Final Thoughts

By taking these steps, employers can help protect their business from potential liability and ensure that all employees feel safe and respected. With proper preparation and the right processes, HR teams can effectively manage employee claims while protecting their company’s bottom line.

Expanding knowledge in legal matters is possible with a few clicks. Get access to various legal insights and stay informed to make better decisions.

Scroll to Top